The Food Historian
  • Home
  • About
    • In the Media
  • Projects
    • Blog
    • Book
    • Food History Happy Hour
    • Book Reviews
    • Podcast
    • Newsletter
  • Resources
    • Food Historian Bookshop
    • Recorded Talks
    • Historic Cookbooks
    • Bibliography
    • Food Exhibits
    • TV and Film
    • Wassberg Food Library
  • Contact
    • Media Requests
    • Speaking Engagements
  • Events
  • Members
    • Join
    • Patreon
    • Members-Only Blog
    • Vintage Cookbooks
    • Manuscript
    • Thesis
    • Other Publications

Food History Needs Historians

2/13/2016

0 Comments

 
 No really.

You would think that with a field title like "food history," that historians writing books on that topic would be a given. Not so. In fact, I think it would be safe to say that at least 50% of the books marketed today as "food history" books are, in fact, written by people with little to no historical training at all. Journalists, scientists, home cooks, chefs, literature majors who like food, and people who think history is cool.

Which is great! I love people who love history. I just don't think that they should necessarily be writing authoritative food histories. 

Maybe that makes me a heretic. After all, I'm also the type of historian who refuses to use the word "an" before the word "historian." I can't help it - I'm an Americanist. We pronounce the aitch. 

But frankly, with a few notable exceptions, most food history books I've read as of late have been disappointments. In fact, the whole field is a bit of a disappointment. Many publishers seem to think that the history of a particular ingredient qualifies as "food history." Or the history of a recipe, or an ethnic cuisine. And these books may, indeed, be writing about the histories of these individual bits. But that does not, in and of itself, qualify as food history.

Because unlike most books published today, REAL food history is history first. If you wrote a science book about the ocean and spent more time describing the marine wildlife than you did actually presenting your research, you'd be laughed out of the academy. But this happens to food history all the time. Authors get caught up in describing things without actually analyzing them. 

And that's where the trouble lies. History is all about taking primary sources, putting them in context, and drawing inferences about the lives of the people who lived in the past, and what their lives and actions mean for the present. The missing "ingredient" from most modern food histories? The people. 

After all, what is the history of the tomato without people? Tomatoes didn't domesticate themselves. In fact, without the context of humanity and its quest for edibles, tomatoes really don't matter at all. 

True history answers the "so what?" question in a way that many modern food histories just don't seem to. Even some of the better histories written by academics which try to make themselves relevant by making connections to modern issues don't do a particularly good job of it. These attempts at relevancy often seem like something tacked on the end of the book at the behest of the publisher, rather than being rooted in the inquiry itself.

Because I'm more public historian than true member of the academe, for me the study of food and especially food history should help us illuminate our own ideas, pre-conceived notions, and biases about food, agriculture, and eating. WHY did we domesticate tomatoes from a tiny wild fruit? WHY did our food production system shift from home-based production to factory-based? WHY do we struggle so much with figuring out what is "healthy" to eat? 

Food history is not an island. You need the context of agricultural history, transportation history, culinary history, ethnic history, political/policy history, the history of what is in fashion, the history of etiquette and manners, women's history, slave and servant history, the history of science.... I could go on.

Food is an inextricable part of our lives. It is literally the ONE THING that connects all humans across all times and spaces. Even the deaf, blind, mute, and/or paralyzed still need to eat and drink. It connects us in a way that language, art, music, dance, storytelling, and just about any other form of communication cannot. 

To analyze it without context is just criminal. 

In summation - if you want to write about food history, please do! But give the study of history just as much or more attention as you do the study of food. And publishers? Please vet your food history manuscripts by academic historians. Everyone, including future researchers, will thank you. 
0 Comments



Leave a Reply.

    Picture

    Author

    Sarah Wassberg Johnson has an MA in Public History from the University at Albany and studies early 20th century food history.

    Become a Patron!

    Archives

    January 2021
    December 2020
    November 2020
    October 2020
    September 2020
    July 2020
    June 2020
    May 2020
    April 2020
    March 2020
    February 2020
    January 2020
    December 2019
    November 2019
    October 2019
    September 2019
    August 2019
    July 2019
    December 2018
    April 2018
    October 2017
    December 2016
    September 2016
    August 2016
    May 2016
    March 2016
    February 2016
    December 2015
    October 2015
    September 2015

    Categories

    All
    16th Century
    17th Century
    18th Century
    1920s
    1930s
    19th Century
    20th Century
    Abolitionists
    Advertising
    African American
    African-American
    Agricultural History Journal
    Agriculture
    Alcohol
    American Red Cross
    American Southwest
    Apples
    Armistice
    Autumn
    Avocado
    Beverages
    Birthdays
    Black History Month
    Book Review
    Breakfast
    Breakfast Cereals
    Cake
    Camping
    Candy
    Canning
    Celery
    Chilis
    Chocolate
    Christmas
    Citrus
    Civil Rights
    Cocktails
    Cold Weather Cooking
    Colonialism
    Columbian Exchange
    Community Cookbooks
    Consomme
    Cookbook Authors
    Cookbooks
    Corn
    Coronavirus
    Cranberries
    Dairy
    Dessert
    Dinner And A Movie
    Documentary Film
    Election Day
    Farm Cadets
    Farmerettes
    Farm Labor
    Fast Food
    Florida
    Flowers
    Food History Books
    Food History Happy Hour
    Food History Roundup
    Food Library
    Food Preservation
    Food Waste
    Gardening
    Gingerbread
    Grape Nuts
    Hal And Edith Fullerton
    Halloween
    Halloween Candy
    Hard Cider
    Heirloom Fruit
    Heirloom Vegetables
    Historic Menus
    History-bites-podcast
    History Channel
    Holiday
    Hollywood
    Home Economics
    Hot Chocolate
    Hot Cocoa
    Hot Dogs
    Ice Cream Soda
    Ice Harvest
    Ida Bailey Allen
    Indigenous
    Indigenous People's Day
    Interstate Highways
    Invalid Cookery
    Italian Food
    Kitchens
    Laura Ingalls Wilder
    Lecture
    Long Island
    Meat
    Meatless Mondays
    Medieval
    Melon
    Mexican
    Mexican Food
    Military
    Milkshakes
    National War Garden Commission
    Native Foods
    New England
    New Year's Eve
    New Year's Resolutions
    North American
    Parties
    Patreon Perks
    Peanut Butter
    Picnics
    Podcasts
    Political Cartoon
    Polynesia
    Pork
    Potatoes
    Preserve Or Perish
    President's Day
    Prohibition
    Propaganda
    Propaganda Poster
    Pumpkin
    Pumpkin Pie
    Pure Food And Drug Act
    Quick Breads
    Racism
    Radio
    Rationing
    Recipes
    Refrigeration
    Riots
    Road Food
    Root Beer
    Salads
    Saratoga Chips
    Sauces
    Shopping
    Soda
    Soda Fountains
    Soup
    South American
    Soviet
    Spanish Flu
    Speaking Engagement
    Special Offer
    Spice Islands
    Spices
    Sugar
    Summer
    Thanksgiving
    Theodore Roosevelt
    Tomatoes
    USDA
    Valentine's Day
    Vegan
    Vegetarian
    Weddings
    White Christmas
    Wild Rice
    Women's Suffrage
    World War I
    World War II
    World War Wednesdays
    Writing
    WWII
    Year In Review

    RSS Feed

Home
About
Blog
Resources
Events
Contact
Membership
The Food Historian is an Amazon.com and Bookshop.org affiliate. That means that if you purchase anything from any Amazon or Bookshop links on this website, or from the Food Historian Bookshop, you are helping to support The Food Historian! Thank you!
Become a Patron!